Middle East

PALESTINE

 

 

 

Foreword

of the Comintern (SH)

In response to the following letter from the Ugandan comrade we added a critical comment of our Egyptian comrade

 

[Criticism and self-criticism are a corner stone of the world Bolshevik development of the Sections of the Comintern (SH).

Either Arabic or Jewish workers - they all belong to the army of the world proletariat and fight in solidarity for the overthrow of world imperialism in preparing the world socialist revolution, for the establishment of the dictatorship of the world proletariat, forf world socialism and its further development towards world communism.

Of course, all this also applies to the unity of all members of the Comintern (SH), in particular.]

 

Every Land of hate will burn

The Forgotten people of Palestine

( Apartheid in the 21st century)

 

Letter

sent from an Ugandan comrade

 

I write this in memory of the Holocaust, the glorious victorious soviet Red army liberated Nazi concentration camps especially Auschwitz and many more other ghettos. I always read on our website and I will not contradict the official statement of the Comintern on the commemoration of the Holocaust in Auschwitz. I also write from the words of my comrades Hazem who has fought against Israel occupation from when he was around 18 now currently an old man, from the books I have read from polish Jews, American Jews, Iraqi Jews and Jews from Netherlands, France who are my friends and also belong to the linage of King David of the Bible, Palestinians and friends of mine who have deep knowledge about the Jewish question.

"I declare war to the death of dominant nation chauvinism. I shall eat it with all my healthy teeth until I get rid of this accursed bad tooth" Lenin ( collected works vol33 P.372)

Its very bad to seeing or hearing experiences of the people who died in Nazi concentration camps of Auschwitz because they were not criminals but only because of their ethnic background(blood). Developing prejudice on people because of their blood is the worst thing that can be formed, people are judged on the basis of something they didn’t decide, that’s how they came to this world it like laughing at a lame or blind person there is nothing they can do.

And truth for Auschwitz if it wasn’t for the Red army to fight the Germans the Jews in Eastern Europe could have been no more. It’s important to thank the Red army for liberating these areas especially Poland, Ukraine, Hungary up to Berlin not only for the liberation of the Jews but also because they fought heroically and saved the world from Fascism.

The Jews are not the only ethnic minorities in this world there are also Palestinians and many others worldwide who have fallen victims of the rich, powerful and immoral society and have been judged on that basis. I remember Apartheid in South Africa, the Armenian massacre, the Rohingya Muslims, the Uighur in China, Tibet unrests and also now the Palestinians in Israeli occupied territories.

These people have suffered a lot in this world at the hands of the people who look at blood as a tool of judgement. It's important to note that Jews started roaming the world because they were business people, educated people and also some loved to tour new areas and this is the reason as to why they exist all over the world. I have a friend who told me his great uncles lived in Turkey and others in Germany. I have also another group from Netherlands who are from David’s real family line they have relatives in France, Germany, United Kingdom they identify themselves from family names. when the Jews left their “homeland Israel” they left some people there and through various changes the Palestinians remained and provided a natural continuation of the the people of those contested areas. Maybe others sold land, others gave it out to friends freely and others left it vacant. It’s important to note that Jewish migrations started a long many centuries ago. Because of the growing prejudice that was existing all over the world especially with the occurrences in Nazi Germany and occupied lands the British was compelled to find and allocate to them a Homeland. They gave them Palestine but remember it had it had it’s original inhabitants and besides long time ago people were migrating from their original homelands for different reasons. If the e everyone is supposed to go back to their homelands the whole world will become unsettled you see. Let’s all be rational in all our decisions.

The Jewish Homeland was awarded to the Zionists

The Zionists have a pessimist and reactionary ideology. The idea of Zionism comes from an idea that no nation can exist without common boundaries. So it came in to solve the Jewish question however it has continuously proved incapable because of it’s romance with the fascism an British imperialism. And this is the cause of the constant wars in the region.

The goal of Zionist ideology was redefined, according to this pro-Palestinian narrative, as the racial separation of Jew from non-Jew.

The Zionists have learnt a lot from Hitler’s DNA tactics where by to be part of them they even have to check your DNA up to RNA. So when they check and find it matching that’s how they confirm. Many have been turned down especially Africans and some Americans who are poor and thus they are seen as would be propagators of social problems in the Apartheid state. Its evident today Israel isn't annexing or occupying Palestinian territories because there is over population in Israel or anything but because of the great hate of the state towards the Palestinian people. They want land not the people on it.

But if Hitler wanted a country of only pure Germans from German backgrounds and Israeli Zionists today want a country made up of pure Jews only what’s the difference between those 2 ideologies it’s just the similarity.

Case study 1

"I was born in West Bank occupied Palestine, I have aright to go to my home there. However they don't want us to return there, but any Jew born anywhere in the world can travel to be a citizen of Israel" Comrade Najeeb

Welcome to the world largest oppressor entity the world Zionism, which has continuously developed it's mechanisms in order to obtain sympathies from the world as it continues it's oppression. Today very many people have feared talking about the subject of Palestine because they fear being labelled anti Semitic but I will. Before we go far what's the meaning of anti Semitic. Anti-Semitism is a prejudice against the Jewish people whereas Zionism is just a policy of developing a national homeland its a radicalized ideology. you have to understand these issues such that you don't get misquoted.

Zionism = Fascism

Anti – Zionism ≠ Anti-Semitism

The Zionists in Israel have always used anti-Semitism to protect themselves from scrutiny, just like a young child who whenever you correct him/her they cry thinking that you hate them. That's why many people have always feared writing even about them.

The world didn’t learn from South Africa, Nazi Germany and today it's grooming an apartheid fascist regime, the biggest enemy to the freedom and peace of the people of the world. The whole group of people is suffering just because of their birth( ethnicity) how they were born the "Palestinians". The truth is that there is nothing the Israelis have against Palestinians apart from that they are Palestinians. The Palestinians are being killed everyday by bullets and bombs shot at them just because of their ethnicity, something that can never changed or something that was never decided by them before birth. How do you expect to hit some one and go away with it, you should expect something exactly or more than what you did.

Zionism= Anti-Semitism “The Jewish islands was awarded to Zionism”

Zionism is also anti Semitic, you can't understand Zionism without Tracing and tracking back to the foundations of the formation of the Zionist state of Israel. Zionism is a reactionary theory based on bourgeoisie Ashkenazi chauvinism which puts Anti Semitism at it's vanguard. They have used anti Semitism to gain sympathy from many Nations and other people however many Jews especially the black Jews and Shepardi Jews have remained oppressed so basically the only difference from their lives before and after is that before they were oppressed by strangers and today they are being oppressed by their brothers.

I don't know whether in the framework for the establishment of Israel it talks about creating a separate state for the Ashkenazi Jews in the Middle east or for all Jews. This is because much as the world is fighting anti Semitism the Ashkenazi have still remained the largest anti Semitic people in Israel hating others on the basis of where they came from

The Ashkenazi normally say that” It’s us who suffered the most look at what happened during the Holocaust these other groups lack this experience” so they think this places them at different levels.

"At first they we were saying our homeland is Israel on reaching there, they began hating each other according to the countries they came from"

Many Jews especially those who were originally in Palestine and those who migrated from Arabic Nations ( Morocco, Egypt) have been segregated because of their roots in those countries and believe these could be potential Arab spies( most of them spoke only Arabic) and thus making them a danger to National security. Even the Jews who were originally in Palestine are now also taken as threats and yet these people sacrificed a lot for this state. Jews from Arab states aren't Jew enough one time Shimon Peres referred to the Shepardi Jews as “Khomeinists” and advised them to go back to their countries of origin. He even said “ you will be beaten like your Arab brothers”.

They have faced problems securing jobs in government offices and are given insensitive jobs because they fear they could be double agents.

The black (Ethiopian) Jews have been segregated because of their color, and most of them are kept in a prison system , killed without Justice, live in Ghettoes in fact some are being deported to African countries along with Immigrants to Rwanda and Uganda. It only appears as though the Jews couldn't migrate to sub-Saharan Africa. They make themselves (Ashkenazi) appear as the most important group of Jews that deserve a better life in the found Homeland as though others are just meant to be around.

Karl Kautsky says " Hostility towards non native sections of the population can only be eliminated “when the non-native sections of the population cease to be alien and blend with the general mass of the population. That is the only possible solution of the Jewish problem, and we should support everything that makes for the ending of Jewish isolation."

I don't know if there is a term for hate of Palestinians but it's important to note that these Zionists especially Benjamin Netanyahu not only hate Palestinians but also Africans they are terrible racists. These people have also developed high pride and look at themselves as the most important people on Earth without talking into consideration the other people who want to live as well. It's important to note that the whole Palestinian people are suffering in this world because of the other people who believe that they aren't people worth living with. Israel is no longer a Jewish state it's a fascist state built on blood of the Palestinians and other minorities.

Anti-Semitism means spreading enmity towards the Jews, the Zionists should understand that there is a difference between an institution and the people. Among all tribes, religion, ethnic groups there are good and bad people there is no one thing that is perfect but Israeli is so imperfect.

V. I. Lenin:

"It is not the Jews who are the enemies of the working people. The enemies of the workers are the capitalists of all countries. Among the Jews there are working people, and they form the majority. They are our brothers, who, like us, are oppressed by capital; they are our comrades in the struggle for socialism. Among the Jews there are kulaks, exploiters and capitalists, just as there are among the Russians, and among people of all nations. The capitalists strive to sow and foment hatred between workers of different faiths, different nations and different races. Those who do not work are kept in power by the power and strength of capital. Rich Jews, like rich Russians, and the rich in all countries, are in alliance to oppress, crush, rob and disunite the workers"

Vladimir Lenin Lenin’s Collected Works, 4th English Edition, Progress Publishers, Moscow, 1972 Volume 29, pages 252-253

In this document I question the subject of allocation of the Palestine land to the formation of the state of Israel and prove the existence of deeply rooted imperialism and racism in its foundations.

Why did the world wait for death of millions of people to respond, why does justice come after loss of lives. Is it that those people who died didn't need this justice? I always tell people human life is so precious that nothing can buy it and there is no one who is important more than the other. I will want to say is that the world made a errors in the resettlement of the Jews/Zionists in Israel was a 2 sided question but the United Nations with a driver gave a one sided answer.

Israel was selected for resettlement because many Jews all over the world looked at Israel as their original Homeland how about the people who were staying there they also consider it a Homeland. Many blacks in America also consider Palestine their home land because they consider themselves Jews there are also African tribes ( Ethiopia, Zambia, Uganda, Malawi , Nigeria, South Africa say they are Jews and the Jewish connection has already been established, besides I am also a Jew should we be loaded onto a plane to Israel. No this can't happen because we are great people, family and we consider are considered their very own. Most of us who read a lot will understand that the formation of the state of Israel was not benefit Jews but the Zionism and the imperialist.

The creation of the Jewish state was mostly facilitated by the bourgeoisie imperialists who looked at it as an opportunity. The problems of the middle East and Palestine in particular have originated from the goals of these countries especially Britain and the United States. The Zionist bourgeoisie Americans wanted to displace the British colonialists because they realized that the area has Natural resources especially oil and gas that would be very important. There fore it's more of an imperialist Outpost rather than a state. The imperialists looked at a reason to take it from the original inhabitants and found nothing to do rather than stage a concert of reclaiming it as a Jewish Homeland.

Comintern:

"A glaring example of the deception of the working people of oppressed nations by the united forces of imperialism of the Entente and the bourgeoisie of these nations is the Palestinian adventure that is being put forward by the Zionists (and Zionism in general, which, in claiming to establish a Jewish state in Palestine, in practice is advocating the expulsion of the Arab working people from Palestine, where the Jewish workers constitute only an insignificant minority, a role that is exploited by Britain.)"

The biggest problem the British and Americans (UN) belittled the already existing people in Palestine, they decided to take it as if they were making a choice between the Jews and Palestinians so they made their choice. Their choice made the Palestinians second class citizens and yet they were found there naturally. They never fought a war to chase away the Israelites during the old times But when Zionists came they built up militias with the help of the US, killed people, looted areas and forcefully migrated Palestinians to other countries. The Palestinians we're now mostly flown out as refugees to Canada, Jordan and so many other countries in other words " the UN principle in setting up Isreal was settling to unsettle". After that the Jews in Israel started getting armed by the United States of America and Britain which fueled war in the region and more wars are coming.

The issue was psychological and they handled it politically, and this is what has created problems about the existence of the state of Israel and also world problems because the methods used were too coarse. The psychology behind the Arab Israel conflict was not that of hate for the Jews ( anti-Semitism) but on the existence of the state of Israel. As everyone knows there are many Jews in Iran, Lebanon, Algeria, Tunisia, Jordan, Syria, Egypt, Saudi Arabia and exist there happily and have never left to the Israel however these countries current foreign policies are against the existence of Israel. This should bring your mind to alertness.

Karl Kautsky: “Yet the Bund is resisting this only possible solution, for it is helping, not to end but to increase and legitimize Jewish isolation, by propagating the idea of a Jewish “nation”

If I was part of the UN or British I would have proposed that the Unit should have brought Jews to unoccupied lands or even give them money to or encourage the Jews to buy large lands in Palestine such that they don't be seen as aggressors. With this they could buy more and find themselves happily coexisting with the people. In fact there were already Jews who had lots of land before Israel was established. A one state solution for both Jews and Palestinians enjoying equal rights and freedoms. Let's not just hurry at answering but let's focus on the approach it's adjustment and adaptability at play.

The mere armament of the Jews by the British and Americans meant creation of a military state which attaches it's existence to the gun and army. Remember also Palestinians have brothers, friends and comrades who could also train and arm them. Even though the British and the Americans have the best weapons they can't be fired without a person behind them. So it's people who fight wars not machines and there are always loses on either sides. Up to today there are Hezbollah brigades giving Israel a hard time threatening all cities and Haifa, we have Islamic Jihad, Fatah brigades, Islamic Jihad and so many others surrounding Israel. Israel up to today can not exist without the gun and I will tell you they aren't free, look at Israel with hate around it, all of it fenced with a net with motion detectors, fighting everyday, sirens everywhere, underground bunkers, terror attacks threats every day and they call it secure. Being secure my comrades starts from not the gun you hold, but psychologically and emotionally paranoia is also insecurity for example, I don't think anyone can harm me because I have no problem with anyone, when it happens it's just an accident. Therefore now Israelis have been programmed to that. You have to raise a gun to take down a gun and anything taken away from you by force can only be taken back by force.

The issue isn't that your taking, the issue is how your taking it comrades let me give you an example when a person asks for a dollar you may help but when he punches you and steals it he becomes a thief that's a different case. Long time ago the grandfather to my polish friend was being sent away from Poland to either Israel or Canada he couldn't go to either countries until the chance came he went to the United States of America his worst fear was the military Zionist state of Israel I mean it’s future.

The Palestinians have been portrayed outside the world by imperialist media as terrorists because maybe of hijackings and so many other things that the Israeli state considers terrorism. However I have asked myself what's the difference between a rebel, terrorist and a revolutionary, how we define them Isn't how the American foreign policy describes them. People fighting for their rights can be called terrorists because they are against the interests of the United States of America or Israel. For example Hezbollah is a terrorist group according to the United States but it's not a terrorist group according to the European Union and other countries Even the Islamic revolutionary guard corps was declared a terrorist organization.

The Palestinians aren't terrorists they are a group of people over 13 million people living in occupied territory and all over the world. They aren't only Moslem but also belong to the Christian faith and other denominations. The reason for Palestinian hijackings and so many other issues is because of the annexation of Palestine. It’s important to note that people globally started getting to know and understand the Palestinian struggle because of the hijackings. You don't steal people's things and then expect them to chant for you. These Israelis soldiers also fire live bullets killing and causing permanent injury to people. Every day there are news on the television Israel kills 8 Palestinians, the world doesn't ask it's self why are they killing them, the world just says " at least today they killed few".

The Jews who perished at Nazi concentration camps were mostly good people who loved the freedom of others today if these people would be looking at what the state of Israel is doing to other nationals they would have rebuked it 100%. My evidence is that I have read books about The history of the great grandfather's of the Israeli people before the Nazi came I have read books about families in Odessa Ukraine, Poland very welcoming and hard-working people who wouldn't forget their friends or fail to help other people.

The Israeli Zionist politicians have hated the Palestinians because of their heritage, they always cry when anything is said against them calling it "anti-Semitism" but that's what they are doing to others. He says he is against people who oppose the legitimacy of the Israel Nation. Benjamin Netanyahu the Israeli prime minister had this to say when ICC announced that they wanted to probe alleged war crimes in Palestinian occupied territories “The ICC only has jurisdiction over petitions submitted by sovereign states. But there has never been a Palestinian state". This means the state of Israeli doesn't think their exists a Palestinian nation. He looks at the Palestinians as nothing more than rocks that need to be cleared away so that they can build homes( settlements). The imperialists in collaboration with the Zionists have stopped Palestinians from getting Justice In fact even joining the international criminal court and international court of Justice has taken a lot of time.

I will not be sorry to say that most of the Israeli politicians ( because I haven't met many people) are the same like the Nazi leader Hitler especially Benjamin Netanyahu. I say so because the politicians have power to influence and enact laws and direct national policy. Every day we say Hitler was bad why was he bad, it's because he judged people on the basis of blood and race especially the Jews. Is the situation different from Palestinian occupied territories

Everyday in Palestine people are being killed or chased away from their lands in order to build settlements for the superior people, every day people are being killed because they are seen as animals what is this. Even the state of Israel Nation is copying the Nazi tactics do you see West Bank, Gaza how are they different from the Lodz Ghetto in Poland and concentration camps established in Nazi occupied territories.

The ghettos we're fenced off and every Jew found leaving the Ghetto had to be shot, it's the same as what is happening to Palestinians. The Jews in Ghettos had to smuggle in food through tunnels in order to supplement their diet and that's what Palestinians are also doing in occupied territories and Israel calls that a crime same as Himmler used to say to their great grandfather's. Imagine basic need have to be smuggled into Gaza every day, their are no jobs there and people aren't allowed to move out, no functioning hospitals and no electricity sometimes. People don't have houses to sleep in, they sleep in temporary structures because Israel hasn't yet approved building materials to be entered there as a punishment. No aid is allowed to reach Palestinians with out approval from the Israeli army and it imposed a naval blockade on it. Every thing even people coming in and out have to be permitted. They have been fenced off like wild animals in the zoo.

The innocent people are living a life of a besieged army, these people sometimes text me and send photos you will never believe what you see, people killed in yesterday's night air raid, a person shot yesterday by the Israeli army such touching things. Israel also employs cluster tear gas canisters dropping them on Palestinians heads during their peaceful demonstrations.

The situation is so bad comrades there is malnutrition, diseases, poverty and lack of housing and anything that makes life worth it. The Israel state wants people in occupied territories to get fed up and leave the area so that they can take over it without any alarm bells in the world, it's like " when you want to get honey you smoke the hive, bees run away and you take the honey without any sting". So answer are Palestinians terrorists or not?.

"When they bomb or shoot in-discriminately at us and we loose lives nobody talks about it, but when we respond the whole world labels us as terrorists" comrade Fatima.

The Zionist state of Israel is taking Palestinian occupied territories as labor camps. Always aiming at exploiting the labor of these poor people. Off course due to stagnation of the economy as a result of sanction by Israel and punishment there is nothing to do apart from going to Israel to find work because there is hardly any job in the occupied territories. In Israel they work mostly at construction sites where the salary is some how better but in the end it's all exploitation. For any Palestinian worker to work in Israel he needs a special permit. These permits are given out in anyway according to the feeling of the institution providing them. Most of the time the Israeli institution giving out Permits give out a few permits such that more people can enter Israel illegally and thus do hard work for cheaper pay at different areas and times. most times their employers pick them at various border points where they assume to be undetected. Most of the poor youth go there to get jobs only to be exploited for cheaper pay because of the lack of permits. In the end Israel also taxes these Palestinians of their hard earned cash and in the end it rebounces back to them.

Keeping Palestinians in an aid vacuum, the united nations and other imperialists don't want to look and bring forward a permanent solution to the Palestinian question. The major reason is because aid is also an important weapon of war mightier than the guns, because you can never fight a person who feeds you. Today we look at more than 80% of the Palestinians depending on aid. They have lost their farm lands which are continuously being absorbed into Israel territory which makes them very vulnerable to food insecurity. This justifies that the imperialist system wants to change the destiny of strong men into a continuous state of poverty so that they can be beggars who base their lives on the feelings of others. They look only at providing them with aid. Just imagine if Palestinians had food and Israel closed the borders, who would be affected no one, but today when borders are closed off what happens I h

The people who are against Palestinians includes the United States of America, Canada and the United kingdom and other allies. These people are the leading cause of problems between the Jews and Palestinians they arm the Israel state with far advanced weapons and money which makes all this possible.

Some of the Palestinians who go to Israel have been recruited by Israeli security agencies. Not all Palestinians are your brothers and not all Jews are your enemies there was and there is still betrayal from fellow Palestinian brothers. The bourgeoisie Palestinians aided the conquering of Palestinian land by the Zionists and it's still occurring because of their selfish needs. Thousands of rich Palestinians were selling land to the Zionists, or aiding them acquire Land through deception ( buying Land on behalf of someone) which gave them a strong foothold in the nation. This is because Land is a private property and any one who acquires it can use it for his own purposes and it's on this land that militias were trained and Zionist arms were stock piled. Up to today there are some Palestinians especially the youth who work for Israel intelligence agencies in the occupied territories. They do this for money and other issues in regard to self interest and most of these are recruited when they go to find work in Israel. Their Network show that they go to Israel and report back sometimes as they deceive that they are trying to find work there. And this has been a serious block in the liberation of Palestine they are the ones impeding it because betrayal leads to more martyrs and many more. There has also been disunity among the Palestinian liberation movements and it's important that some of these organizations work for Israel let's not forget that. It's not okay to criticize fellow comrades but many of these have remained passive and have also adopted unpopular policies and others are devoting their energies to fighting each other. Look at Palestinian authority which works with Shin bet and Israel defense forces to suppress any Palestinian resistance to the occupation. They are also supported by the imperialists because they do their work.

The PLO is looking at the Zionists living together in peace and harmony but what is happening to Palestinian families living inside Israel. These people are being segregated even in provision of services with Israeli communities being developed as Palestinians are being left out. Many Palestinian communities lack clean running water, schools and hospitals are located so far away, roads aren't being constructed, There is no electricity for these families, segregation from employment, people need permits to go into other areas from the Israeli defense forces which take long to be approved and also lack of security from extremist Zionist groups which attack and vandalize property belonging to Palestinian especially vehicles and homes. And yet Israeli settlements are built with everything they need to survive.

Betrayal of Palestine

The Arab Nationalism against the ottoman empire and the Zionist Chauvinism of wanting a Jewish only led to Palestinian betrayal. The Arab brothers to Palestinians sold them out to the Zionist at a cheaper cost. From 1919 till today Arab betrayal plays a central role in suffering and killing of Palestinians. From the secret deals Emir Faisal Ibn Hussein made with Zionist leader Weizmann where he pledged his support for the Balfour Declaration in exchange for Zionist support for an Arab state combining former Arab States of the dis-integrating ottoman. The Balfour declaration never even mentioned Palestinians, it instead just related to them as "Non Jewish population". Palestinians are struggling with out Identify cards have constantly remained as refugees for example it's important to note that in Lebanon Hezbollah is providing temporary identify cards to Palestinians to help them access some services but before these refugees had nothing to show. Even the Arab States have denied Palestinians to secure residency, employment broadly to say citizenship even though they have lived in these countries for over 2 generations especially in Lebanon. Saudi Arabia is siding with the Zionist regime and more Palestinians are being arrested there. Today the Arab Nations have money but they are the poorest in the world in terms of unity they concentrate today on politics of religion, military arms of which non is a warrior and are also Chauvinists, they just oppose the indiscriminate killing of Palestinians on paper, gone is the solidarity of Abdul Nasser and Hafez Al Assad. Today Saudi Arabia is like a person who has gotten a lift in the friends car, anytime your friend can change where he's going and then decide to keep you on the way anywhere and you will have to say thank you". Saudi Arabia is appreciating Trump's peace plan for Palestine because it's an ally of the United States of America and also a secret development ally of Israel, so there is no way it can afford going against their choices. There is a Saudi campaign in Yemen and it wants to position it's self as a regional leader therefore it needs Military hardware and there is no where it can get it except from these traitors. The United States of America have always played an ignorant and subjective role in "policing" this world, how can you design a peace plan for conflicting parties and you only involve one party. It’s important to note that there were also Arabs who were among those who launched the plan especially ambassadors of Bahrain and Oman. Your totally dishonest. The peace plan looks at free annexation of Palestinian territories with Palestinian communities remaining very minute like small slums

Slave camp

Canada because of its small population and harsh conditions is using war in other I countries as luck in getting people to come in especially as refugees. These groups of people have almost declared the Palestinian people a stateless nation. And Canada is benefiting from the annexation of Palestinian territory, this is because many have been forced to flee and then become refugees. Canada always gets funds from the United States of America to resettle these people into Canada. They are being taken in because Canada has few young people (labor force problems) and many people aren't venturing to go there because of its harsh climate. They are forcing people who had a settled life in Palestine to move as refugees what a curse. Curse in which way, Canada has receives a lot of snow and is always very cold in most cases, the standards of living are more than Palestine, they have to deal with family problems of separation. First of all these people lost their homeland to invaders and they will never be allowed to return by Israel which means complete separation, there property is also taken by the Israeli state. It's important To note that Palestinians were a continuation of the old people who lived there along time ago. The term homeland encompasses many things first of all culture, history and status. There is no Land whether Los Angeles, London or Toronto that is better than anyone's home country. They are just chilling zones for us who have never been there. These Americans , British and Canadian are conspiring behind the Palestinians and giving the Zionist powers green light to annex and do whatever against the Palestinians.

There are also many Somalis, Congolese Rwandans and other refugees, how is Canada playing a role to make these people go back to their homelands. About the United States of America is that it's the existing curse to the human race, they look at people's life as an Xbox or Play station game where everything follows your control but the world is tired of you.

The world can never give justice to anyone just now, the red Indians lost their land and they have never been compensated and face a number of bad policies that make life seem unbearable in the United States of America. Look at the black man who was sold no reparations, no even a sorry. Poor people of the world are being exploited everyday. Change is you and it’s in your hands

The hope of the future isn't in the hands of the Palestinian liberation organization or any other organization which looks at just begging the imperialists for their liberation. The oppressed people should know that there is nowhere in history where the oppressors have negotiated themselves out of power.

Israel isn’t mightier than said they say, it has been defeated by Hezbollah( just a para military group) at multiple fronts so there are many examples.

The Liberation lies in the hands of the Palestinian people, in the revolution which will replace the old order. Which will bring forward a free united Palestine of happy, United and righteous people( Arabs and Jews) which will be part of the Communists federation. Say no to imperialism and stump out Babylon.

 

For a socialist communist world revolution

Forever onwards to victory★

Ugandan comrade



Old poster of proletarian internationalism

among Arab and Jewish workers


 

In addition:

A critical comment

of our Egyptian comrade

 

In a reply to the Ugandan comrade

Hereby dear comrade I present to you some points of "comments" to the Ugandan comrade, in a comradely spirit, excuse me in case if my accent was kind of sharp.

 

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

"I declare war to the death of dominant nation chauvinism. I shall eat it with all my healthy teeth until I get rid of this accursed bad tooth" Lenin ( collected works vol33 P.372)-

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*Here Comrade is using something that is relevant, comrade Lenin here refereed to russia when it was oppressing many nations, Russia itself was a nation that was oppressing many other small nations, but concerning the subject here, we are already needless to say that the Palestinian cause and the Arab-Zionist conflict isn't a fight between a nation and the other, it's a fight between a nation, and that arab people of palestine whom their lands were occupied by force, not only "racism" , not only "chauvinism", and Israel as we know won't stop only in Palestine, for it has further plans.

* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

So it came in to solve the Jewish question however it has continuously proved incapable because of it’s romance with the fascism an British imperialism. And this is the cause of the constant wars in the region.

The goal of Zionist ideology was redefined, according to this pro-Palestinian narrative, as the racial separation of Jew from non-Jew.

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*Zionism Dear comrade, was through my personal study and as I have read many Zionist litreature preceisly of Hertzel, was kind of old idea that was created among some of the Jewish thinkers in the countries where they faced a great state of opression like in russia and then finally it came to "practice" through Hertzel world Zionist movement which was given birth in real life through the British imperialism, so zionism can not only be defined as "racial separation", it's a very deep ideology that as you yourself has defined had aims through it's masters of world imperialism, and not only this but to creat a historical genocide against the Arabs in general, in any country, to make this "supperior" race upon all the others.

* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

They want land not the people on it.

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*They want to extend on the whole Arab land, and not only Palestine.

* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

The Zionists in Israel have always used anti-Semitism to protect themselves from scrutiny, just like a young child who whenever you correct him/her they cry thinking that you hate them. That's why many people have always feared writing even about them.

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*that's a very good example you tell us here comrade, in reality the term "anti-semit" itself originated from the religious mytheology that the Jewish were the sons of Noah's Sam, but the irony of fate is that themselves weren't the only one sons of Sam, for the Arabs too were his sons. (that's according to the mytheology)

* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

The whole group of people is suffering just because of their birth( ethnicity) how they were born the"Palestinians". The truth is that there is nothing the Israelis have against Palestinians apart from that they are Palestinians.

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*The whole group of people, or the Arab nation in general are suffering from israel for that this fascistic entity which was created by the leaders of world imperialism and the fascist Zionists to ensure their profits, to kill and expell a whole Arab nation from it's lands, and the later matters to me the most before any other reason as an Arab.

* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

I don't know if there is a term for hate of Palestinians but it's important to note that these Zionists especially Benjamin Netanyahu not only hate Palestinians but also Africans they are terrible racists.

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*All of those who stand and live in Israel or out of it, consedring it a legal state, trying to defend it, are actual Zionists, Benjamin, who is nothing else but a tongue for this entity basically expresses the whole body of this "Zionist nation" on our lands, so never comrade think that there will ever be some "good" Israeli, for I don't believe that at all, and I also need to point out to you that they also (the Zionists) have a network in Latin America, their network and their Zionist propaganda in Africa didn't only stop there. it extends it's net everywhere, even here after the natural shameful positions of the arab traitorous leaders who they all should taste the painful death.

* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

The biggest problem the British and Americans (UN) belittled the already existing people in Palestine, they decided to take it as if they were making a choice between the Jews and Palestinians so they made their choice. Their choice made the Palestinians second class citizens and yet they were found there naturally.

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*From my point of view, they weren't making choice, they knew very well the consequences of their political adventures against the arab people, but everyone knows that anything else can go easy for money, and that what has happened, the israeli fascist occupiers themselves didn't care so much for the "decisions" made by the UN, they went as they loved, they didn't care for anything, while our leadership through it's fight sadly had "manhood" with the Israeli fascist scums and stood for "peace" with them, and later the Zionists exploited the chance and crushed us to the bones and our army.

* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

however these countries current foreign policies are against the existence of Israel. This should bring your mind to alertness.

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*If you comrade follow the Arab media, I can ironically tell you, all of the kings, the presidents, all of them without exception, are nowdays in "open" relationship with Israel nowdays, they tell us fuck the cause and fuck the martyers, we care about the benfeits only, and that's normal for the burgeoisie morals.

* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

If I was part of the UN or British I would have proposed that the Unit should have brought Jews to unoccupied lands or even give them money to or encourage the Jews to buy large lands in Palestinesuch that they don't be seen as aggressors. With this they could buy more and find themselveshappily coexisting with the people.

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*apart from this dream comrade, and apart from the fact that the Arabs actually would never and they didn't as many other bourgeois Zionist propagandists try to claim that the Arabs sold their lands to the Jewish migration, the Israelis in reality came with blood, so they will also leave with it and will be crushed and kicked out of the homeland, that's inevitable.

* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

I have asked myself what's the difference between a rebel, terrorist and a revolutionary, how wedefine them Isn't how the American foreign policy describes them. People fighting for their rights canbe called terrorists because they are against the interests of the United States of America or Israel.

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*that might be a good point to talk about, well world imperialism, including Zionism, has created the best conditions for the birth of this very "wide" and sea like term of "terrorism", that they even call the smallest democratic here in Egypt a terrorist or "agent" , bla bla bla,..

so imagine when you kick a people out of their homeland, you claim that their lands is yours, you oppress and kill them in an Auschwitz like prisons and you declare war on others, how and what reaction could you have imagined to be after all these horrors committed not only against the Arab people in Palestine, but against our whole Arab nation?

* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

The Palestinians aren't terrorists they are a group of people over 13 million people living in occupiedterritory and all over the world. They aren't only Moslem but also belong to the Christian faith andother denominations.

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*and here comrade we come to another point of view, we should not at all look from this point of view, the Palestinians, are a part from a nation that they share the language, the borders, the history and the blood with it, it's called the Arab nation, every other "muslim ,christian, or even jewish" point of view should be neglected, for it only serves the reaction, the concept of the proletarians of this nation should be the only thing that appears among the angry masses, and not other fanatic dogma away from the actual factors which creates the people as only one nation and nation(s) and people(s) despite the ancient special history of every country.

* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

Every day we say Hitler was bad why was he bad, it's because he judged people on the basis of bloodand race especially the Jews. Is the situation different from Palestinian occupied territories

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*But comrade, was Hitler really bad only for "judging"? I mean, you know very well the rotten power which moves with the Hitlerite demagogy and has mad it remove many people in Europe from the face of the earth entirely, including the Jewish ethnic. The Israelis, as Hitler, are not only bad, but they need to be crushed, they need no more terms to describe their fascistic intention and their lackeys in the homeland, they all including the Arab reaction to be shredded to pieces and to be thrown to the dogs.

* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

The people who are against Palestinians includes the United States of America, Canada and theUnited kingdom and other allies. These people are the leading cause of problems between the Jewsand Palestinians they arm the Israel state with far advanced weapons and money which makes allthis possible.

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*Do you comrade mean a countries (aka:governments) or you mean a people (nation) that support Zionism? For if it's the last one you mean, then I assure you, there is some good anti-zionist positions taken by at least many there. But that's for sure to point out that also some of it are anti-israel allegedly from a "Nazi" point of view which we totally oppose for it's facsistc ideas and denying for the masscares committed against the Jews of Europe!

And here comes another fun fact, that Hitler and Mussolini were supporting Zionist fascist groups like Lehi (Stern Gang) who they have massacred mercilessly many Palestinians and they later became a builders for the Israeli Occupying Army.

* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

Some of the Palestinians who go to Israel have been recruited by Israeli security agencies. Not allPalestinians are your brothers and not all Jews are your enemies there was and there is still betrayafrom fellow Palestinian brothers. The bourgeoisie Palestinians aided the conquering of Palestinianland by the Zionists and it's still occurring because of their selfish needs.

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*What you say here comrade doesn't help at all, for it's being used directly or indirectly as a propaganda for the service of Zionists. They tell that trying to make a "fact" out of it, and that the "people there are living and going throug the various state sectors"... all what I can tell about those traitors of the homeland is the same comrade Enver Hoxha told about the Albanian traitors, so did the Albanian traitors represented the real will of the Albanian people and the Albanian proletarians? at all.. and that's how we should act concerning the traitors. The only one thing that awaits the traitors from the Arab side is a historical punishment and enternal death in the history's dumpstin. That's what awaits the Arab bourgeoisie in Palestine or Egypt or anywhere either in Arab country or any other country , only the death and the shame for their actions and position.


* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

The Arab Nationalism against the ottoman empire and the Zionist Chauvinism of wanting a Jewishonly led to Palestinian betrayal. The Arab brothers to Palestinians sold them out to the Zionist at acheaper cost. From 1919 till today Arab betrayal plays a central role in suffering and killing ofPalestinians.

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*I don't know if you comrade have a background of Arab nationalism, but Arab nationalism in these times against the Ottoman and the colonialists was a good movement and a progressive bourgeoisie democratic one. Many of it's thinkers were in the beginning arousing with secular ideas and calls for unifiyng the nation which was torned apart to pieces through the imperialists and their plans. For sure the world imperialists like the English exploited the revolt by Al-shareif Hussein in Al-hijaz to take the place of the Ottomans, but the movement in it's very deed were not a one of betrayel at all. It was calling for the total liberation of the homeland, that the Comintern itself taught to the Arab communists to take part  in it (and sadly they failed to do so), to give the masses a content that it's national in it's outview and communist in it's crux and nature. The betrayel actually didn't came from Arab nationalists, even the fascist Saddam who has massacred mercilessly many Iraqi Arabs and Kurds and espically the communists, didn't dare to betray Palestine as happens today in the Arab countries by the kings and presdients who didn't only betray Palestine and sell it, but they also went telling the Egyptians: you are no Arabs! Fuck Palestine! Fuck their cause! They also went to tell the Morocoans and the Algerians: you are Berbers, why you should care about Palestine ? Fuck them! The Arabs themselves in the Arab Gulf are being told by the lackeys of world Zionism and imperialism: you are Arabs true, but why you should care for a pile of terrorists (!!??) . There is a hug gap between the Arab nationalism which was born in order to liberate the whole Arab world and unify it in a single Arab state instead of these "Nation(s)" and "People(s)". So they can at least gain and have their national diginity which the Arab people are in need of it in these dark days.

* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

gone is the solidarity of Abdul Nasser and Hafez Al Assad. Today Saudi Arabia is like a person who has gotten a lift in the friends car, anytime your friend can change where he's going and then decide to keep you on the way anywhere and you will have to say thank you".

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*Hafez actually was a big traitorous pig, Abdul Nasser went so far and established a fascistic regime built on oppressing the progressive democrats and the workers of Egypt who even went to help him like the revisionist Shahdy Ate'ya the "famous communist" of Egypt who has died in the prison due to a "torture party" for that he was only a "Marxist" (supporting Nasser) while he was a Dimitrovian who destroyed himself and sold the Egyptian communist movement to the Egyptian fascist executioners. True that Nasser supported Palestine like no one ever before, but his mistakes, his relies on the Soviet social imperialism and before it his "hopes" on the American imperialism which proved to him to be nothing, his wavering position towards the old state apparatus and the reactionary feudal lords of Egypt (most of them). All of these things were playing a horrible factors in the defeat which came to a result of  an internal counter-revolution, the defeat of the Arab nation and Egypt on the head against the war against Israel.

While Hafez was an alleged Arab "nationalist" Ba'thist, the history of October liberation storm had it's testimony on his shameful acts, starting from leaving the Gulan to the Israelis, and passing by his betrayal to the Arab troops from Morocco who have seen death and were later helped by the Iraqi armed forces. So it's so complicated, dear comrade to equally treat or to specifiy the history of the birth of Arab nationalism which has degenerated and became a mere false, for the only one real patriots in the Arab homeland are not the nationalists and the fascists here, they are the communists. The Arab communists are the only ones who care about the fate of their nation's workers and their homeland's total liberation.

* * *

Quote of the Ugandan comrade:

The Liberation lies in the hands of the Palestinian people, in the revolution which will replace the oldorder. Which will bring forward a free united Palestine of happy, United and righteous people( Arabs and Jews) which will be part of the Communists federation. Say no to imperialism and stump out Babylon.

Comment of the Egyptian comrade:

*Yes comrade, but through what? And that I personally wish the solution for us, for we know that there is many kinds of "revolutions" as you know, but in our era, the only one patriotic, revoultionary, and real democratic class is the proletarian class and nothing else wich will guarantte the happiness of the whole people. But in the case of Palestine, it's necessary for the Palestinian working class to unify itself and make itself a unified detachments with the All-arab red army in order to expell the Israeli occupier from the homeland, to retake Sabta and Malela, to liberate Al-ahwaz from the fascist Iranian occupation. So either a socialist revolution that creates a revoultionary proletarian red army in the Arab countries that whipes out from the face of the earth the Arab bourgeoisie, the Zionists and their reactionary lackeys in the homeland, the scums of world imperialism, or we can just dream and dream many times about a solution. The solution is an armed liberation and class struggle against both, the occupier, and the Arab bourgeoisie which co-operated with the occupier and in it's service.

Only through this way, we can create a real-free and democratic Palestine and transform it to the Soviet Socialist Arab Republic of Palestine and unify it with the All-arab Soviet Socialist Republic, a socialist republic which equally treats all the workers of the world including the Jewish workers who were and still decieved by the Zionist scums of the earth. A soviet Palestinian Republic which puts to trail all the Israeli fascists to be court-martialed and also the scums of the Arab reaction and bourgeoisie, and even the revisionists who destroyed the struggle of the Arab working people in Palestine.


* * *

 

Despite all this dear comrade, and despite that there is a times I wish as an Arab the matter of Palestine could be settled in some "utopian" way, through some "one click" solution, to see the Arab lands taking it's actual Arab identity in front of the whole world and the Arabs and the Jews who have suffered alike living in fraternity and without any hatred, but everytime I see a massacre or a horrible killing against my Arab people brothers in Palestine it boils the blood in my veins that I want to revenge from every Israeli believing in his stupid fascist dream and living on the Palestinian Arab lands.

I hate Israel from the depth of my heart, and I know that many others and the masses hate it the same but they don't know the solution. But as for the question of the Jews stay in our lands that will bring us to the jewish in Israel themselves, if they struggle against Zionism with the Arab people we will certainly welcome them in our lands for they had no mistake to be born here on an occupied land accidently, but to see a Zionist insist on his intention by the calls of "peace" and we should forget about the matter of the Arab identity of our land (THE WHOLE OF IT) and our martyrs, then this will leave us no other option but to kick out every Zionist from our land, either by force or by peaceful means.

In the end, dear comrade, I totally understand your good intentions, but I needed to write these comments just to clarify many things concerning what you wrote.


Greetings Comrade